Officers
| Joe Mastruserio | President |
| Ronald A. Panioto, Jr. | Immediate Past President |
| Anthony Dilbert | Vice President |
| Edward Rubeo | Treasurer |
| Maria Carver | Recording Secretary |
| Carmine DiLonardo | Financial Secretary |
| John Helbling | Orator |
| Carmen Capozzolo | Guard |
| Steve Caminiti | Master of Ceremonies |
| Joseph Geraci | Sergeant at Arms |
| Jerry Gonnella | Chaplain |
| Mary Ellen Begehr | Good Will Ambassador |
Trustees
| Mike Camacci |
| Mike Geraci |
| Doug Newell |
| Gary Tedesco |
| Pete Scalia |
State Delegates
| Concetta & Mike Geraci |
Cincinnatus Lodge 1191 recognizes its members who hold higher offices at the State & National levels
| Mary Kovach | |
| Grand Lodge of Ohio, Treasurer | |
| National Sons of Italy Foundation (SIF), Trustee | |
| National Commission for Social Justice (CSJ), Ohio Representative | |
| National Office, Advisor | |
| National Membership Commission, Chair |